Election 2012 | Web Preview

Election Day 2012: Watch Guide and Predictions

Published: November 6, 2012, 11:53 am ET
Assistant Online Editor

Here we are. Election Day 2012. Tomorrow, you’ll wake up and either wear a righteous smirk or a miserable frown to your 9 a.m. That’s because by then, you’ll know who won the Presidential Election -— hopefully.

As you watch the results —- or turn off the television and social media to avoid them -— here are some keys to look for both candidates, and a prediction of who will be in charge until 2016.

Let’s start with the safe state electoral count:

Obama 207Romney 191, 11 states to go

Now let’s start breaking down the 11 swing states:

Michigan, Pennsylvania, Virginia, Florida, North Carolina, New Hampshire, Wisconsin, Nevada Colorado, Iowa and Ohio

Michigan, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin were once safe Democratic states, and if they don’t go blue, that’s a bad sign for Obama. So watch early on. If one turns to Romney, expect a very tight race, or a likely Romney win. As of now, the President is polling about four points or ahead in each of these states. Advantage Obama.

Obama 247Romney 191, 8 states to go


If North Carolina and Florida appear to be trending toward Obama, that’s a bad early sign for Romney. Polling there has been strong for Romney throughout the fall, having been strengthened after the first debate. Advantage Romney.

Obama 247Romney 235, 6 states to go

In Ohio, Obama is polling three points ahead, which combined with a fast recovery and the auto bailout, should give Ohio to the President. Historically, a three-point lead in a state the day before Election Day holds up well. Advantage Obama.

Obama 265Romney 235, 5 states to go

Now we get into the true toss-ups that will decide the election. If the other states go as I’ve predicted, the race will come down to Nevada, Iowa, Colorado, New Hampshire and Virginia. The polls here are all within just two points. To win, Obama needs to win just one state.

Let’s start with Virginia. Obama’s defense spending cuts affect Virginia jobs more than the rest of the country, but the unemployment rate is low, and Virginia’s economy has recovered faster than average. All told, Virginia could go either way, but based on past voting history and the apparent strength of Romney with independents, I’ll say Advantage Romney.

Obama 265Romney 248, 4 states to go

In Colorado, the polls have Obama up by .6%, the race is tied, but the Obama camp has two advantages. One, marijuana legalization is on the ballot, which should increase youth turnout slightly. They also have 55 state offices to Romney’s 14. However, the state’s Latino vote is less loyal to the Democratic Party than average, and Colorado remains a western, largely white state. Romney should eke out a win here, but it will be a very close race. Advantage Romney.

Obama 265Romney 257, 3 states to go

Iowa and Nevada make things interesting. Obama appears to have a slight lead in Iowa, which relies heavily on government farm subsidies and has a low unemployment rate of 5.5%, compared to the national 7.8%. However, the large evangelical population may be more enthusiastic to vote and turn the tide. On the other hand, Nevada has a very high unemployment rate of 12.2%, but Democrats have a 90,000-plus registration advantage, and early voting appears to favor Obama. Advantage Obama in Nevada and, Iowa. New Hampshire could go either way.

Final prediction: Obama 281Romney 257

The President should win a second term thanks to favorable electoral math, but the popular vote is a different story. Thanks to a depressed turnout in New York, New Jersey and Connecticut from Hurricane Sandy, expect a razor-thin margin, and a possible Romney popular vote win. In the Electoral College, expect a close race all night, but if the early predictions in this article start to switch sides, a national late-breaking trend that sweeps Romney into office is possible.

What do you think? It’s a very close race, and I’m likely wrong somewhere. Do I have it a little wrong? Horribly wrong? Give your take.

Contact staff writer John McAuliff at

Related Article Topics

, ,
Comments »
To post a comment, leave your first and last name and a valid e-mail address. Comments may not appear immediately because they must be approved by a moderator before posting. No registration is required, but you may sign in with DISQUS, Facebook, Twitter, Yahoo, or OpenID.
  • Not surprised

    A UR student picks Obama to win? What a shock. Could we be a more liberal campus?

    • Amanda S., Westhampton ’12

      I do hope you’re joking; I think the students at UR have a wide variety of views. This is a great article, John.

    • Ray Troy

      Yes. Easily. UR is relatively conservative compared to most campuses. More of a 60-40 split than the typical 75-25 split.

      Also, Obama is a heavy favorite to win. The news organizations reporting it as a “toss up” are doing their statistics wrong. Consider this: No individual poll in Ohio shows Obama winning by more than 3 points. They see that and say “toss up.” But if you look at the 20 latest tracking polls taken in Ohio, you’ll see that Obama leads by 1-3 points in 19 of them. This is not what you would expect in a toss up situation (ex. a coin flip).

      Nate Silver, a statistician who started out as one of the original baseball sabremetrics (Moneyball) guys, has now applied this same sort of model of statistical analysis to politics. In 2008 he called 49 of 50 states correctly (with the exception of Indiana, which he called for McCain, but which went to Obama by 1 point). He has Obama winning in 85-90% of possible scenarios, primarily because of his swing-state “firewall”. If Obama wins Ohio, Romney would basically need to win everything else, and his chances of that are low.

      This is not a toss up.

  • JustMe

    Obama all the way, I’d rather have a president who is trying, then a president who is lying

  • Reilly Moore

    Great analysis. More impressed by this than any of the other projections or predictions I’ve read today. Glad to see this kind of coverage in The Collegian.

  • Long

    Chicago will win.

  • Kyle

    Obama is telling the truth. Romney dosen`t know what he is doing.

  • Long

    But what of Joanita? Please do not forget her because racial equality has won abroad – we must fight on the home front? Yes.